The following is a little exchange on the comments section of ZMan's excellent post, Letter To The Antisemites. Perhaps I was little harsh on the fellow, but at the same time he did compile a large spreadsheet full of risible nonsense. If he amends his spreadsheet and comes up with more of an argument than an insinuation, then he'll do himself and fellow right thinkers a big favour.
No rush. 
I never began to suspect that Jews (or a subset of Jews) might have a habit of degrading or undermining goy nations until the beginning of this year (and I’m 53 now). But Jews also seem to have gotten themselves kicked out of places an astonishing number of times — at least 350 times over the past 2700 years. A newcomer to the JQ would have to wonder why.
I never began to suspect that Jews (or a subset of Jews) might have a habit of degrading or undermining goy nations until the beginning of this year (and I’m 53 now). But Jews also seem to have gotten themselves kicked out of places an astonishing number of times — at least 350 times over the past 2700 years. A newcomer to the JQ would have to wonder why.
@Aitch748_the_Дeplorable Don’t be such a cocktease, tell us why, my good friend.
I can only guess that they kept getting kicked out of places because they kept causing problems for the people who lived there. Kind of like how, if everybody in a town hates this one person, maybe the problem isn’t all the haters, maybe the problem is HIM?
Anyway, I made a spreadsheet listing where and when Jews were expelled from places, based on info I found on Gab (if @thezman will allow the link). Feel free to download and comment.
“I can only guess that they kept getting kicked out of places because they kept causing problems for the people who lived there”.
Do you have evidence that this happened EVERY SINGLE TIME?
Failing that, do you have evidence that this happened most of the time?
Failing that, do you have evidence that this happened a sizeable number of times?
Failing that, do you have evidence that this happened most of the time?
Failing that, do you have evidence that this happened a sizeable number of times?
Straight out of the gates, I have a very good reason to believe that you did not compile this spreadsheet in order to look into the JQ with an open mind:
In ten entries, including the very first two, you cite expulsions of Jews from their own land. If you are not intelligent enough to understand the difference between being *getting yourself kicked out of someone else’s land* and *being expelled from your own land*, then I suggest you avoid further publicising your stupidity by linking to this spreadsheet.
Of the ten I referred to, the most strikingly stupid by far is this:
Line 330:
1948, West Bank and Jerusalem, Jews expelled.
1948, West Bank and Jerusalem, Jews expelled.
My not-so-very-clever friend, the more I read of your spreadsheet, the more strongly I advise you to spend less time compiling mindless lists and more time thinking these things through.
Embedded in the JQ is a genuine critique of Judaism’s attitude to non-Jews — hence my other comment to ZMan — but if you rely on such obviously shoddy research and weak arguments, I guarantee you that there are plenty of Jews and non-Jews who will humiliate you in a public debate; and what’s worse, the only people who will find this material persuasive will be even less intelligent and more unbalanced than you.
No comments:
Post a Comment